Pension industry bodies have welcomed plans to automatically consolidate millions of small pension pots, but are calling for clearer rules on protecting members’ benefits and greater certainty over how the system will operate.

The Department for Work and Pensions’ (DWP) consultation on its Multiple Default Consolidator model for small pots closes this week (17 November), with responses focusing on trustee discretion, implementation costs and the ability of consolidator schemes to handle large volumes of transfers.

Under the proposals, deferred defined contribution (DC) pots worth £1,000 or less and inactive for at least 12 months would be automatically transferred into authorised consolidator schemes from 2030, unless members opt out.

The government estimates that around 20 million pots could be eligible by implementation. There are currently more than 13 million deferred small pots, costing the industry approximately £240m annually to administer, according to the DWP’s research.

The government proposes that pots containing guarantees or protected benefits should generally be excluded from consolidation, but would allow trustees and scheme managers to exercise discretion where the benefits of transferring outweigh existing protections.

“We need robust safeguards to protect valuable pension rights, a sensible dormancy period that avoids unnecessary transfers, and consolidators that can demonstrate they can deliver good outcomes.”

Madalena Cain, SPP
Madalena Cain, Society of Pension Professionals

Protections, guarantees, and proportionality

The Society of Pension Professionals (SPP) has called for specified protections – such as guaranteed annuity rates and protected tax-free cash rights – to be automatically excluded from automated consolidation. It also wants a standardised approach to identifying protected benefits, alongside stronger operational requirements for consolidators.

Madalena Cain, deputy chair of the SPP’s DC committee, said: “We need robust safeguards to protect valuable pension rights, a sensible dormancy period that avoids unnecessary transfers when people take time out of work, and consolidators that can demonstrate they have the operational capability to deliver good outcomes.”

The Association of Professional Pension Trustees (APPT) raised concerns about incomplete historical records, calling for transfers to be paused where information about potentially valuable protections is insufficient.

Law firm Sackers, meanwhile, questioned whether leaving decisions about protected pots to trustees and providers would be workable for pots of such limited value.

Ferdinand Lovett, Sackers

Ferdy Lovett, Sackers

Ferdy Lovett, partner at Sackers, said: “We are calling on the government to reconsider plans for trustees and providers to exercise discretion over whether to consolidate pots with guarantees or protections, as the costs and administrative burden could quickly become disproportionate to the value of the pots.”

Both Sackers and the APPT have called for a safe harbour protecting schemes and trustees that comply with their duties.

The APPT also wants clearer rules on what happens when transfer notices are not successfully delivered, including when schemes should trace members or use alternative communication channels before proceeding.

Costs and delivery under scrutiny

The infrastructure needed to support automatic consolidation has also come under scrutiny, with concerns that new systems could duplicate existing industry capabilities.

Angela Staral, People's

Angela Staral, People’s Partnership

Angela Staral, chief operating officer at People’s Pension, said: “The industry and policymakers have a once-in-a-generation opportunity to tackle one of the biggest inefficiencies in the pensions system, but we need to think bigger than consolidating existing small pots. We need a long-term solution that can support secure, efficient, and low-cost transfers at scale, both now and in the future.”

The Investing and Saving Alliance has urged the government to adopt open technology standards rather than rely on a single provider, warning that a proprietary system could restrict competition and increase costs for savers.

Technology specialist Lumera, meanwhile, questioned how much functionality should sit within the proposed central digital interface.

Maurice Titley, commercial director, data and dashboards at Lumera, said: “Strong governance does not mean that every part of the solution needs to be built centrally. The central interface should focus on those functions that genuinely need to be delivered centrally, while schemes, consolidators and their providers undertake matching and transfers through secure, interoperable solutions.”

Sackers also warned that the framework must remain aligned with wider Value for Money and scale reforms to avoid pots moving repeatedly between schemes. The Value for Money framework will include provisions to force consolidation of underperforming schemes, while the government’s drive for scale in DC could also put pressure on schemes to consolidate.

The DWP plans a further consultation in late 2027 or early 2028 covering the detailed duties of transferring schemes, supervisory arrangements and final data standards, ahead of the planned 2030 rollout.