Vidett’s Ben Salmons explores how defined benefit pension schemes can prepare for a potential endgame, whether it is an insurance transaction, run-on, or another option.

Ben Salmons, Vidett

Ben Salmons, Vidett

Innovation is opening new possibilities for defined benefit (DB) pension schemes. The recent regulatory clearance of TPT Retirement Solutions new superfund is a case in point, alongside new approaches to risk transfer, insurance products and technology.

Better funding, new legislation and a wider appetite for running on have given trustees far more choice than they had a few years ago, but that choice is only useful if a scheme can act on it. Therefore, the question is no longer whether the options exist, but whether schemes are ready to use them.

Keeping on track

A scheme can have a clear endgame objective without being ready to deliver it. Reliable data, suitable investments, a surplus policy and effective governance are essential, but so is agreement between trustees and the sponsoring employer.

Trustees don’t want to spend years preparing for an insurance transaction, only to discover that the sponsor has concerns about the accounting implications. Regular discussions can help identify such obstacles before they derail a strategy.

Running on brings different challenges. Improved funding may create opportunities to generate and share surplus, but this requires more intensive monitoring, reporting and governance. A scheme may therefore be strategically prepared but lack the practical arrangements to deliver its plans or have its data and investments in good shape without agreement on its destination.

This is no longer a debate about how to begin innovating. Superfunds have been cleared; insurers keep refining their products and new technology keeps arriving.

The questions to consider are whether trustees can access these solutions, whether the wider industry can support them at scale, and whether schemes can help shape them rather than simply receive them. That can be uncomfortable for governance models designed around a different set of circumstances: boards are being asked to assess structures that did not exist when their processes were set.

Tech support and its limitations

Technology could improve efficiency, data portability, risk measurement and member engagement, but much of the industry’s infrastructure was built for a different purpose. Traditional administration systems were designed to maintain records and pay pensions over decades, rather than support today’s volume of transactions and transfers.

Extracting information can involve considerable manual work, particularly when the necessary data was never collected. Technology can help identify gaps and make transfers easier, but resolving inaccurate or missing records still requires expertise and investment.

Once dashboards become available to members, increased engagement could also place further demands on already stretched administrators, at a point when connecting by the deadline has already absorbed much of their capacity.

Trustees need to think beyond becoming buy-in or buyout ready. Being transition-ready means having the data, investments, governance and stakeholder relationships needed to assess insurance, superfunds, consolidation and run-on strategies without committing prematurely to one destination.

Scheme readiness is only part of the challenge. There is also a question about whether different solutions face a level playing field. Superfunds face lengthy clearance processes, while arrangements such as employer transfers may not face equivalent hurdles.

Innovations introduced by established insurers can also be easier to adopt within familiar regulatory structures. Member protection must remain paramount, but unnecessary barriers could restrict the options available to schemes.

What does innovation mean for members?

Crowd of people

Greater choice and more efficient transactions are only part of the picture. Much of the progress currently focuses on making transactions easier or creating options for schemes and sponsors.

While valuable, this does not automatically improve members’ experience or outcomes. The real test is whether innovation strengthens the security of members’ benefits, improves their experience or delivers better retirement outcomes.

The priority now is ensuring schemes have the infrastructure, governance and confidence to embrace innovation, while giving trustees a say in shaping what comes next. Above all, it must deliver for members, not simply make it easier to move schemes from one arrangement to another.

Ben Salmons is a client director at Vidett.